Thursday, 24 October 2013

Final Post - Third Episode, Feedback & Reflection

3rd & Final Episode

Editing the final performance was done over two editing sessions. In the first session I was able to get everything done aside from exporting the file. When we filmed the episode, we decided on a different lighting setup to the first 2 episodes. Due to the fact that there were 3 performers for the this episode and we only had 3 lights, we couldn't set up front and back lighting for all of them. It also would have been dangerous to set up back lights behind the guitarist because he might have bumped into it and burnt himself. Instead we decided to go for a stylized look by making very obvious and purposeful shadows cast onto the walls behind the performers. Initially I wanted to use the square and rectangle padding blocks on the walls as canvases for the shadows to make something extra visually interesting but somewhere along the way it became more and more difficult to maintain as the musicians were moving around more than we thought they would.

A problem with the performance clips is that the camera I was shooting with had trouble handing the lower half of the room. The carpet was darker than the walls and made the image much darker when shooting the lower half of the room. I wasn't entirely sure how to fix this in the edit so I chose to make the performance somewhat stylized by making all of the shots that were primarily focused on the lower half of the room black and white. In addition to this I used a bunch of sliding transitions to give it a light-hearted feel that went along with the style of the music the band came up with. This was a style of editing I hadn't really attempted before and on reflection it perhaps was not the best decision but at least I tried something new. Editing video usually gets me tired and frustrated but trying new editing styles was a good learning experience.

In the second editing session all I needed to do was export the video. The first time I tried to do it I was using one of the Macs at VU that apparently has a reputation for being slow. It went well for the most part but it stopped exporting at around 97%. So I had to cancel it and try again on one of the other Macs. The first time I tried on that one there was an issue with the export codec so I had to export a third time. And it worked.


Feedback

We received feedback from 2 of our sound engineers (Matthew Bombaci and Drew Campbell) and 2 of our performers (Katy Maximos [in reference to her solo episode] and Tim Francis [Automatic, Everywhere]).

Of the sound engineers, both of them said that Bruce and I were organized, that the project was run in a professional manner, that they enjoyed being a part of Brain Squeezed Jam and that they would help out again if given the opportunity. Matthew suggested that we utilize only 1 sound engineer for each session rather than 2 and that the location could be changed for some variety in the episodes. Drew noted that he would like to see some interview footage with the creators for some extra context.

Of the musicians, both of them said that they would not consider their songs to be complete and Katy said that she will be finishing hers. Both noted that they would want to change the lyrics of their songs. Katy said that the experiment has not influenced her to change her writing style but would consider using different instruments and experiment more, while Tim noted that rather than the blindfolds, writing against a time limit was something that he would try again. Both of them noted that they thought the time limit was something that would be very effective in getting past writer's block.


Reflection

The concept has come a long way from when I first thought of it in class during week 2. It came out less entertaining than I was expecting it to end up but that is possibly due to the fact that we decided to shoot around a pop/rock based style to try to appeal to a wider audience. If I were to revisit this format I would want to try it with heavier rock music in order to pacify my own interests. We thought that shooting an episode with a band would be much harder than a solo or duo but it turned out to be very similar. It was unfortunate that their bassist couldn't be there for the episode, I would be very interested to see how it would be with a complete band.

I am very glad that we put in a great deal of effort to make it look and sound as good as it could be, the audio is excellent and I would have to say that of all the footage we have put on Youtube I am very happy with the way Katy's solo performance turned out, I believe it is the best of all that we have done. This is the first time I've been involved in shooting something so organized for the web, if I were to continue doing this I would hope that the production time would be a lot quicker in order to get more content up.

Bruce was the perfect person to work on this with. Aside from the fact that he is a music student and has access to Kindred Studios for free and knows musicians and engineers from VU, he is a very organized person and passionate about music. If I was to attempt this on my own it wouldn't have turned out half as good as it is. Our combined enthusiasm kept us going this past year and of all the assessments I have completed during my course, this will be the one that I am most proud of.

The experiments and performance videos can be found here:
http://www.youtube.com/brainsqueezedjam

Wednesday, 2 October 2013

First Episode Response + Second Episode Editing

Last week we uploaded the first episode and the first performance video. In the 9 days they've been up so far the first experiment video has received 73 views and the first performance video has received 40 views. I wasn't entirely sure what sort of numbers to expect but I'm happy with that. I've noticed a few people sharing the videos around Facebook as well which is encouraging.

Yesterday Bruce and I began editing the second episode and performance video. Once again I handled the performance video because Bruce has Final Cut on his laptop and can work on the editing later if he didn't finish in the session we spent at VU. I managed to cut the second performance clip much faster than the first, this was possibly due to the fact that my camera shot was mostly the same for the duration of the performance and Bruce's was moving around to get a variety of shots. They blended together really well and I reckon it turned out a lot better than the first one. I also enjoy the song a lot more than the first one, it's very catchy. Bruce hasn't finished the second episode yet as he was having some troubles due to a metronome being recorded alongside some of Katy's speaking moments. I guess it's a good thing we shot for 30-40 minutes, there's definitely footage that is usable. Unfortunate that we can't use the best parts though. Bruce is going to speak to one of the sound engineers who mixed the audio to see if he can get a version of it without the metronome.